wrenchmark

Is the Smart Forfour reliable?

72% pass rate

pass their MOT first time

Cars the same age average 75%

Worse than most

In plain English

72% of Smart Forfour MOT tests in 2025 were passed first time. For cars of the same ages, the average was 75%. That falls from 81% at 6 years old to 66% at 10. The most common reason to fail is lights and signalling (9% of tests), then tyres (8%). The years to avoid are 2015, 2016 and 2017.

MOT tests analysed23,142
Typical mileage at MOT45,000 miles
Typical age at MOT9 years
Cars registered2005–2019

Which years are best?

By year first registered, compared with all cars of the same age, so older cars aren’t marked down just for being older

Best years

No year passed noticeably more often than cars the same age.

Years to avoid

YearPass rateSame-age avg
201566%72%
201671%75%
201776%78%

A year is listed only if it passed at least 2 points more or less often than cars the same age.

Every year
YearPass rateSame-age avgTests
200452.7%57.8%275
200559.4%57.6%802
200655.4%57.1%834
201566.1%72.0%5,396
201670.6%75.0%5,254
201775.8%78.1%4,738
201879.5%80.9%3,771
201981.0%83.3%1,937

Will it keep passing as it ages?

First-time MOT pass rate at each age

Smart Forfour All cars the same age

Age in years

See the numbers
AgePass rateAll carsTests
681.1%83.5%1,982
779.0%80.9%3,743
875.8%78.2%4,841
970.5%74.9%5,417
1066.5%71.8%4,763
1160.4%68.7%336

What usually fails?

Share of MOT tests that failed on each area

Smart Forfour All cars the same age
  • Lights and signalling9%
  • Tyres8%
  • Suspension8%
  • Emissions, exhaust and leaks6%
  • Wipers, mirrors and glass6%
  • Brakes4%

The faults that fail it most

Share of MOT tests failing on each item

  1. Ball joint excessively worn3.3%
  2. Stop lamp: not working3.2%
  3. Tread depth below requirements of 1.6mm3.2%
  4. Catalyst emissions: lambda reading after 2nd fast idle outside specified limits3.0%
  5. Wipers: does not clear the windscreen effectively2.9%
  6. Coil spring: fractured or broken2.1%

What testers warn about

Advisories: not a fail yet, but worth checking before you buy

  1. Tread depth: worn close to legal limit/worn on edge19.3%
  2. Brake discs: worn, pitted or scored, but not seriously weakened11.4%
  3. Tyres: slightly damaged/cracking or perishing10.0%
  4. Brake pads: wearing thin5.7%
  5. Brake discs: worn, but not excessively4.1%
  6. Pins and bushes: pin or bush worn but not resulting in excessive movement3.1%

Buying one? Check it first

Enter the registration to see that car’s own MOT history: every result, the mileage at each test, and what failed or was flagged.

We look the registration up with DVSA and don’t keep it.

Compare it with

Figures cover 23,142 MOT tests of the Smart Forfour in 2025, not counting retests. A pass means no fails at all, so a car fixed at the test centre counts as a fail. Source: DVSA anonymised MOT tests and results.