wrenchmark

Is the Smart Fortwo reliable?

71% pass rate

pass their MOT first time

Cars the same age average 67%

Better than most

In plain English

71% of Smart Fortwo MOT tests in 2025 were passed first time. For cars of the same ages, the average was 67%. That falls from 86% at 6 years old to 77% at 10. The most common reason to fail is lights and signalling (12% of tests), then suspension (8%). The best years to buy are 2011, 2012 and 2014.

MOT tests analysed53,828
Typical mileage at MOT52,000 miles
Typical age at MOT13 years
Cars registered2004–2019

Which years are best?

By year first registered, compared with all cars of the same age, so older cars aren’t marked down just for being older

Best years

YearPass rateSame-age avg
201271%64%
201168%61%
201475%69%

Years to avoid

None. Every year passed more often than cars the same age.

A year is listed only if it passed at least 2 points more or less often than cars the same age.

Every year
YearPass rateSame-age avgTests
200259.4%59.6%325
200359.0%58.8%290
200463.4%57.8%614
200559.8%57.6%726
200658.0%57.1%900
200761.0%57.3%2,007
200862.5%57.4%4,344
200963.3%58.4%5,328
201065.4%59.4%5,018
201168.3%61.3%3,675
201271.5%63.6%4,460
201370.7%65.9%4,411
201474.7%68.6%3,706
201575.8%72.1%2,196
201676.9%75.1%5,688
201780.2%78.1%4,784
201882.9%81.0%3,352
201985.8%83.3%1,869

Which fuel is most reliable?

First-time MOT pass rate for each fuel, against the average for cars the same age

Will it keep passing as it ages?

First-time MOT pass rate at each age

Smart Fortwo All cars the same age

Age in years

See the numbers
AgePass rateAll carsTests
686.0%83.5%1,910
782.5%80.9%3,439
879.6%78.2%4,902
977.3%74.9%5,296
1077.1%71.8%2,372
1173.9%68.7%3,723
1270.6%65.8%4,538
1371.0%63.5%4,270
1467.4%61.2%3,805
1566.4%59.4%5,099
1662.8%58.3%5,212

What usually fails?

Share of MOT tests that failed on each area

Smart Fortwo All cars the same age
  • Lights and signalling12%
  • Suspension8%
  • Brakes7%
  • Tyres5%
  • Wipers, mirrors and glass5%
  • Emissions, exhaust and leaks5%

The faults that fail it most

Share of MOT tests failing on each item

  1. Coil spring: fractured or broken3.7%
  2. Stop lamp: not working3.1%
  3. Position lamp: not working2.6%
  4. Service brake performance: excessively binding2.5%
  5. Malfunction indicator lamp: inoperative or indicates a malfunction2.2%
  6. Headlamp: not working on dipped beam2.2%

What testers warn about

Advisories: not a fail yet, but worth checking before you buy

  1. Tread depth: worn close to legal limit/worn on edge12.9%
  2. Tyres: slightly damaged/cracking or perishing12.7%
  3. Rigid brake pipes: corroded, covered in grease or other material9.9%
  4. Brake discs: worn, pitted or scored, but not seriously weakened6.2%
  5. Brake pads: wearing thin5.2%
  6. Engine oil leaks: leak, but not excessive4.4%

Buying one? Check it first

Enter the registration to see that car’s own MOT history: every result, the mileage at each test, and what failed or was flagged.

We look the registration up with DVSA and don’t keep it.

Compare it with

Figures cover 53,828 MOT tests of the Smart Fortwo in 2025, not counting retests. A pass means no fails at all, so a car fixed at the test centre counts as a fail. Source: DVSA anonymised MOT tests and results.