wrenchmark

Most reliable budget cars

Low-cost makes like Dacia and MG, and city cars like the Hyundai i10. Ranked by first-time MOT pass rate against cars the same age.

Ranked for their age

27 models with at least 10,000 MOT tests, against the average for cars the same age

  1. 1 Suzuki Celerio27,190 tests +7 pts83% vs 76% avg
  2. 2 Volkswagen up!127,002 tests +6 pts80% vs 73% avg
  3. 3 Mitsubishi Mirage11,103 tests +6 pts81% vs 75% avg
  4. 4 Skoda Citigo51,949 tests +5 pts78% vs 73% avg
  5. 5 Peugeot 10876,887 tests +5 pts81% vs 77% avg
  6. 6 Nissan Pixo10,701 tests +3 pts64% vs 60% avg
  7. 7 SEAT Mii18,567 tests +3 pts76% vs 73% avg
  8. 8 Toyota Aygo269,020 tests +3 pts76% vs 73% avg
  9. 9 Vauxhall Viva38,034 tests +2 pts79% vs 77% avg
  10. 10 Hyundai i10250,019 tests +1 pt73% vs 72% avg
  11. 11 Citroen C1162,249 tests +1 pt69% vs 68% avg
  12. 12 Suzuki Alto45,319 tests 0 pts65% vs 64% avg
  13. 13 MG HS32,625 tests 0 pts88% vs 88% avg
  14. 14 Peugeot 107106,732 tests 0 pts61% vs 61% avg
  15. 15 Vauxhall Agila32,643 tests −1 pt60% vs 61% avg
  16. 16 Kia Picanto189,673 tests −1 pt71% vs 72% avg
  17. 17 Ford Ka168,755 tests −1 pt66% vs 67% avg
  18. 18 Fiat Panda84,540 tests −2 pts64% vs 66% avg
  19. 19 MG ZS63,564 tests −4 pts82% vs 86% avg
  20. 20 MG 515,076 tests −4 pts84% vs 88% avg
  21. 21 Renault Twingo23,673 tests −5 pts61% vs 67% avg
  22. 22 MG 324,921 tests −6 pts75% vs 81% avg
  23. 23 Volkswagen Fox23,231 tests −8 pts51% vs 58% avg
  24. 24 Dacia Logan15,049 tests −8 pts69% vs 76% avg
  25. 25 Chevrolet Spark13,308 tests −8 pts54% vs 63% avg
  26. 26 Dacia Duster81,572 tests −9 pts71% vs 80% avg
  27. 27 Dacia Sandero117,448 tests −9 pts69% vs 79% avg

Also in this group

Fewer than 10,000 MOT tests, so not ranked

Price class is where a model sat in the new-car market, not what it costs used: a ten-year-old premium car can cost less than a new budget one. It comes from the make, with a few models moved up or down, like city cars and flagship saloons. Classic cars, vans and pick-ups have none. Points are the gap between a model’s first-time pass rate and the average for cars the same age: 88% against 67% is +21 points. Combine type, fuel and price.