wrenchmark

Most reliable premium cars

Makes like Audi, BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Volvo and Lexus. Ranked by first-time MOT pass rate against cars the same age.

Ranked for their age

89 models with at least 10,000 MOT tests, against the average for cars the same age

  1. 1 BMW M316,286 tests +21 pts87% vs 66% avg
  2. 2 Jaguar F-TYPE15,554 tests +14 pts91% vs 77% avg
  3. 3 BMW Z435,019 tests +13 pts78% vs 65% avg
  4. 4 Lexus IS34,483 tests +13 pts78% vs 65% avg
  5. 5 Lexus RX36,632 tests +12 pts81% vs 69% avg
  6. 6 BMW 6 Series21,579 tests +11 pts80% vs 68% avg
  7. 7 Lexus CT30,930 tests +11 pts83% vs 71% avg
  8. 8 Audi A716,860 tests +11 pts85% vs 74% avg
  9. 9 Audi TT111,339 tests +10 pts77% vs 67% avg
  10. 10 Mercedes-Benz SLK53,898 tests +9 pts72% vs 63% avg
  11. 11 Mercedes-Benz ML28,998 tests +9 pts72% vs 63% avg
  12. 12 BMW X615,953 tests +9 pts83% vs 74% avg
  13. 13 Lexus NX31,726 tests +9 pts90% vs 81% avg
  14. 14 Audi A6122,369 tests +9 pts80% vs 71% avg
  15. 15 BMW 5 Series205,119 tests +8 pts80% vs 71% avg
  16. 16 Audi Q749,823 tests +8 pts83% vs 74% avg
  17. 17 BMW M413,582 tests +8 pts88% vs 80% avg
  18. 18 BMW X592,466 tests +8 pts80% vs 73% avg
  19. 19 Lexus UX16,151 tests +7 pts94% vs 86% avg
  20. 20 Audi Q5117,662 tests +7 pts84% vs 77% avg
  21. 21 Ford Mustang12,668 tests +7 pts84% vs 77% avg
  22. 22 Mercedes-Benz CLS22,003 tests +7 pts75% vs 68% avg
  23. 23 Toyota Land Cruiser21,021 tests +7 pts73% vs 66% avg
  24. 24 BMW Z311,116 tests +7 pts70% vs 64% avg
  25. 25 MINI Countryman113,800 tests +7 pts83% vs 77% avg
  26. 26 Volvo XC7016,610 tests +6 pts69% vs 63% avg
  27. 27 BMW 3 Series477,144 tests +6 pts76% vs 70% avg
  28. 28 Audi Q284,495 tests +6 pts90% vs 84% avg
  29. 29 Land Rover Discovery142,926 tests +6 pts75% vs 69% avg
  30. 30 Jaguar XF93,070 tests +6 pts74% vs 69% avg
  31. 31 BMW X1112,072 tests +6 pts82% vs 77% avg
  32. 32 Jeep Grand Cherokee11,952 tests +6 pts72% vs 66% avg
  33. 33 BMW 4 Series111,522 tests +6 pts84% vs 78% avg
  34. 34 Mercedes-Benz E-Class230,676 tests +6 pts77% vs 72% avg
  35. 35 Volkswagen Touareg36,676 tests +6 pts77% vs 72% avg
  36. 36 Audi A5125,851 tests +5 pts77% vs 72% avg
  37. 37 Saab 9-332,218 tests +5 pts64% vs 58% avg
  38. 38 Land Rover Range Rover Evoque191,080 tests +5 pts82% vs 77% avg
  39. 39 Jaguar I-PACE22,526 tests +5 pts92% vs 86% avg
  40. 40 BMW X3108,258 tests +5 pts81% vs 76% avg
  41. 41 BMW i326,106 tests +5 pts87% vs 82% avg
  42. 42 Mercedes-Benz GLE33,765 tests +5 pts87% vs 82% avg
  43. 43 Audi Q3140,559 tests +5 pts82% vs 78% avg
  44. 44 Audi A3419,373 tests +5 pts76% vs 71% avg
  45. 45 Mercedes-Benz CLK24,921 tests +5 pts63% vs 58% avg
  46. 46 MINI Hatch658,552 tests +5 pts76% vs 72% avg
  47. 47 BMW 1 Series393,694 tests +4 pts76% vs 72% avg
  48. 48 Mercedes-Benz GLC83,961 tests +4 pts86% vs 82% avg
  49. 49 Mercedes-Benz C-Class358,866 tests +4 pts75% vs 70% avg
  50. 50 BMW X418,738 tests +4 pts85% vs 81% avg
  51. 51 Land Rover Defender120,710 tests +4 pts73% vs 69% avg
  52. 52 Land Rover Freelander109,763 tests +4 pts65% vs 61% avg
  53. 53 Volvo XC4088,592 tests +4 pts90% vs 86% avg
  54. 54 Volvo XC60118,909 tests +4 pts80% vs 76% avg
  55. 55 Audi A4242,457 tests +4 pts73% vs 69% avg
  56. 56 BMW 2 Series135,288 tests +4 pts84% vs 80% avg
  57. 57 Jaguar E-PACE32,311 tests +4 pts87% vs 84% avg
  58. 58 Volvo S6019,092 tests +4 pts72% vs 69% avg
  59. 59 Jaguar XE42,772 tests +3 pts81% vs 78% avg
  60. 60 Jaguar F-PACE58,529 tests +3 pts85% vs 82% avg
  61. 61 Audi e-tron17,842 tests +3 pts90% vs 87% avg
  62. 62 Mercedes-Benz GLA91,626 tests +3 pts83% vs 81% avg
  63. 63 Mercedes-Benz B-Class70,825 tests +3 pts73% vs 70% avg
  64. 64 Volvo V7037,872 tests +3 pts64% vs 61% avg
  65. 65 MINI Clubman28,025 tests +2 pts79% vs 76% avg
  66. 66 Volvo XC9074,538 tests +2 pts76% vs 74% avg
  67. 67 Mercedes-Benz GLB12,254 tests +2 pts90% vs 88% avg
  68. 68 Volvo V6041,080 tests +2 pts78% vs 76% avg
  69. 69 Volvo V9016,618 tests +2 pts84% vs 83% avg
  70. 70 BMW X221,265 tests +1 pt86% vs 85% avg
  71. 71 Land Rover Discovery Sport119,869 tests +1 pt81% vs 80% avg
  72. 72 Mercedes-Benz V-Class14,012 tests +1 pt82% vs 81% avg
  73. 73 Mercedes-Benz A-Class365,080 tests +1 pt78% vs 77% avg
  74. 74 Audi A1234,914 tests +1 pt76% vs 75% avg
  75. 75 Jaguar X-TYPE19,142 tests +1 pt59% vs 58% avg
  76. 76 Land Rover Range Rover Velar36,965 tests +1 pt84% vs 84% avg
  77. 77 Mercedes-Benz CLA75,927 tests 0 pts81% vs 81% avg
  78. 78 Audi Q410,659 tests 0 pts88% vs 88% avg
  79. 79 Polestar 213,914 tests −1 pt88% vs 88% avg
  80. 80 Volvo S4015,182 tests −1 pt58% vs 59% avg
  81. 81 Volvo C3020,532 tests −1 pt58% vs 60% avg
  82. 82 Volvo V4096,964 tests −2 pts72% vs 74% avg
  83. 83 Tesla Model 387,272 tests −2 pts84% vs 87% avg
  84. 84 Alfa Romeo Giulietta24,419 tests −3 pts66% vs 69% avg
  85. 85 Mercedes-Benz EQC12,503 tests −4 pts84% vs 88% avg
  86. 86 Volvo V5026,049 tests −4 pts55% vs 59% avg
  87. 87 Alfa Romeo Mito17,146 tests −4 pts61% vs 65% avg
  88. 88 Tesla Model Y34,887 tests −4 pts84% vs 89% avg
  89. 89 DS DS336,071 tests −11 pts67% vs 78% avg

Also in this group

Fewer than 10,000 MOT tests, so not ranked

Price class is where a model sat in the new-car market, not what it costs used: a ten-year-old premium car can cost less than a new budget one. It comes from the make, with a few models moved up or down, like city cars and flagship saloons. Classic cars, vans and pick-ups have none. Points are the gap between a model’s first-time pass rate and the average for cars the same age: 88% against 67% is +21 points. Combine type, fuel and price.