wrenchmark

Most reliable MPVs

MPVs and people carriers, from the Meriva to the Galaxy. Ranked by first-time MOT pass rate against cars the same age.

Ranked for their age

26 models with at least 10,000 MOT tests, against the average for cars the same age

  1. 1 Toyota Estima18,907 tests +10 pts77% vs 66% avg
  2. 2 Toyota Alphard11,553 tests +9 pts73% vs 64% avg
  3. 3 Nissan Elgrand13,924 tests +4 pts67% vs 63% avg
  4. 4 Mercedes-Benz B-Class70,825 tests +3 pts73% vs 70% avg
  5. 5 Toyota Verso26,895 tests +2 pts70% vs 67% avg
  6. 6 Volkswagen Sharan34,916 tests +2 pts76% vs 74% avg
  7. 7 Mercedes-Benz V-Class14,012 tests +1 pt82% vs 81% avg
  8. 8 Volkswagen Touran68,072 tests +1 pt68% vs 67% avg
  9. 9 SEAT Alhambra25,862 tests +1 pt74% vs 74% avg
  10. 10 Skoda Roomster17,388 tests +1 pt64% vs 63% avg
  11. 11 Ford C-MAX105,422 tests 0 pts68% vs 67% avg
  12. 12 Kia Venga46,246 tests 0 pts71% vs 71% avg
  13. 13 Hyundai ix2028,659 tests −2 pts69% vs 71% avg
  14. 14 SEAT Altea12,244 tests −2 pts59% vs 61% avg
  15. 15 Ford B-MAX53,495 tests −2 pts68% vs 70% avg
  16. 16 Ford S-MAX67,691 tests −3 pts65% vs 67% avg
  17. 17 Vauxhall Meriva80,808 tests −3 pts62% vs 65% avg
  18. 18 Volkswagen Caravelle18,201 tests −4 pts65% vs 69% avg
  19. 19 Vauxhall Zafira173,814 tests −4 pts62% vs 66% avg
  20. 20 Ford Galaxy54,877 tests −5 pts64% vs 69% avg
  21. 21 Ford Grand C-MAX34,432 tests −6 pts65% vs 71% avg
  22. 22 Kia Carens13,670 tests −7 pts63% vs 70% avg
  23. 23 Renault Scenic31,778 tests −8 pts56% vs 64% avg
  24. 24 Renault Modus10,164 tests −8 pts50% vs 58% avg
  25. 25 Fiat 500L16,988 tests −9 pts62% vs 70% avg
  26. 26 Renault Grand Scenic18,883 tests −12 pts54% vs 66% avg

Also in this group

Fewer than 10,000 MOT tests, so not ranked

We put each model under the body style most of its cars have, so the Ford Focus counts as a hatchback even though estates exist. Models sold in a real mix of styles, like the BMW 2 Series, aren’t listed. Points are the gap between a model’s first-time pass rate and the average for cars the same age: 88% against 67% is +21 points. Combine type, fuel and price.